Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Musical Surgery: Conclusion

As we look back on my path of destruction, I'd like to remind you that this entire feature exists solely on a hypothetical plane. None of the advice or suggestions will ever matter in the grand scheme of things. I'm sure if the artists in question saw my amended lists, they'd say "How dare this sniveling blog-jockey suggest he understand my artistic decisions more than the artist himself!" They'd be right to feel that way, even if it isn't the case. I know that every album (worth its salt) is carefully conceived, developed and sequenced, taking into account conceptual factors that I am not privy to. I also don't claim to write off any of the featured albums because of my personal belief that they're a bit overlong.

This isn't about skipping tracks, either, because I rarely ever do that (even those I chose to omit in this feature). This is all just critical analysis, simple as that. Again, it's why hypotheticals are such a wonderful thing. They allow for these sorts of exercises without consequence. I'm not going to delete the struck-down tracks from my iTunes library, and burn updated versions of the CDs in question. I tried to take as objective an approach as I could, but I concede that such a thing isn't really possible. But alas, I thought it sounded like a fun challenge, and it proved to be just that.

It bears mentioning that not all long albums require trimming. Wilco's Being There, Sun Kil Moon's April, the Flaming Lips The Soft Bulletin: All examples of long(ish) albums that I wouldn't dream of changing. There are plenty more.

So thanks for keeping up with this month's The Deeper In feature. As always, feel free to submit your own choices for overlong LPs. Meanwhile, I'll be listening to the new Arcade Fire album which, yes, is pretty damned long.


Albums covered:

1 comment:

David Kenny said...

Hi everybody.
I love music. Music brings us interesting things. Interested in music I would like to mention ringtones. Ringtones from famous songs. Hot ringtones. Ringtones are attractive. You can search through my ringtone to get the best ringtone for your mobile phone at my homepage:https://ringtonesmobile.net/

Here are the top 5 ring tones of 2018, you can refer and leave a comment:
- Mere Halat Aise Hai ringtone | ringtonesmobile
- Guru Randhawa – Made In India ringtone | ringtonesmobile
- Prada – Jass Manak ringtone - ringtonesmobile
- Khalnayak Theme ringtone - ringtonesmobile
- Shivba Malhari ringtone - ringtonesmobile

Free ringtones for people around the world. Hope my ringtone will please you. I need your comment to improve the ringtone better. Thank you for your attention!